Clearly Established #12
Welcome to the 12th issue of Clearly Established, a slightly irreverent roundup of recent accountability decisions. It’s been a while since our last issue, but we’re back with a bumper crop of interesting cases. Let's dive right in.
Buckle up, ’cause this first case takes us deep into the abstruse world of interlocutory appellate jurisdiction. Rule 1: Ordinarily, you can’t appeal a case until there’s a final judgment, but denials of qualified immunity (so sayeth the Supreme Court) are special and immediately appealable. Rule 2 (the “Heck bar”): Federal courts cannot hear civil-rights claims that imply a state-court conviction is invalid. So what happens when a district court denies qualified immunity and also rejects a Heck argument? A couple of circuits say you can appeal both, but those courts are wrong, says the Third Circuit. No interlocutory appellate jurisdiction over the Heck bar here.
It’s rare you see an entire panel concur with its own opinion, but three Third Circuit judges do so here to explain the scholarly basis for their decision denying qualified immunity to an officer who shot at a fleeing suspect.
Cop responds to domestic-violence call and shoots deadbeat dad dead. Cop: We chased him, he stopped at a couch, he grabbed something, and he began to turn towards me. I thought he’d gotten a gun! I was in fear for my life! Fourth Circuit: Then how come you shot him in the back? And how come nothing was ever found in the couch? Qualified immunity denied.
Sheriff fires jail guard for sexually assaulting detainees. Sheriff then, inexplicably, rehires jail guard. Guard, predictably, sexually assaults more detainees. Fifth Circuit: It was “plainly obvious” that the guard would sexually assault inmates again. No qualified immunity for the sheriff.
Allegation: Cop, responding to false alarm, shoots two friendly dogs. Eighth Circuit: That sure sounds unconstitutional. Cop: But what if I say they were growling? Eighth Circuit: You can say that in discovery. Qualified immunity denied.
When a protester performs a “die in,” is dragging her out of the room by one arm with enough force to tear her rotator cuff excessive force? No, rules the Ninth Circuit, granting the officer qualified immunity.
Remember that special jurisdictional rule at the top of this issue for appeals of qualified immunity? Well, in the Ninth Circuit, that rule doesn’t apply to denials of sovereign immunity, and so naturally it doesn’t apply to denials of derivative sovereign immunity either. (So many immunities!)
Is it clearly established that public officials can’t fabricate a confession of child abuse to obtain a conviction? Yes, and that’s obvious, says a split panel of the Tenth Circuit. Dissent: But the official in question was a social worker, not a law-enforcement officer; but she was drafting a social-services report, not a forensic analysis; but she couldn’t have known her fabricated report would be used in criminal proceedings; but, but, but….
Black high school student earns a spot on a major university’s “elite dance team.” High school cheer coach, in text messages: “It actually makes my stomach Hurt[.] Bc she’s f*****g black[.] I hate that.” Student discovers texts, shows them to principal; coach is relieved of her duties. Coach then tells the rest of the team to “boycot[t]” student—to ostracize and exclude her from cheer team activities. Tenth Circuit: Might be you violated the constitutional guarantee of equal protection. No qualified immunity for you.
School officials strip search a 14-year-old girl—twice—looking for a roach. They find nothing. Qualified immunity? District court: Well, they didn’t find the roach anywhere else on her, so they just had to strip search her. Eleventh Circuit: Well, there’s a Supreme Court case saying they can’t do that, and a case from this court saying they can’t do that, so they probably should’ve known they can’t do that. Qualified immunity denied.
That’s it for this week. Please feel free to send this newsletter to any friends or family who might find it interesting. If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to receive future issues here.
When we’re not writing this newsletter, we litigate cases in the federal courts of appeals. If you want to support that important work, you can do so here.
Thanks for reading.
